Peer Review Process
Research in the Mathematical and Natural Sciences (RMNS) implements a single-anonymous peer review process to ensure scientific quality, fairness, and editorial independence.
1. Initial Editorial Screening
All submitted manuscripts undergo initial screening for relevance, originality, scientific quality, compliance with author guidelines, and publication ethics.
Manuscripts failing essential requirements may be returned for correction or rejected before external review.
2. Single-Anonymous Peer Review
Under the single-anonymous model:
-
Reviewers can identify the authors.
-
Authors do not know the reviewers' identities.
-
Reviewer identities and reports remain confidential unless disclosure is explicitly authorized.
Each manuscript proceeding to peer review is evaluated by at least two independent external reviewers with relevant expertise who are not members of the journal's editorial board.
A third reviewer may be appointed when additional expertise or further evaluation is required.
The same review requirements apply to regular submissions and special issues.
3. Review Criteria
Reviewers evaluate scientific novelty, methodological rigor, analytical depth, validity of findings, clarity, relevance, and ethical compliance.
The journal uses four editorial recommendations:
-
Accept
-
Minor Revision
-
Major Revision
-
Reject
Authors invited to revise must provide a revised manuscript and a point-by-point response to reviewer comments.
4. Editorial Decisions
Reviewers provide independent scientific recommendations, but the final decision rests with the Editor-in-Chief or an authorized editor.
Editorial decisions are based on scientific merit and publication ethics, not on publication fees, institutional affiliation, or personal relationships.
Submissions involving editors, editorial board members, or closely connected individuals must be handled by an independent editor without relevant conflicts of interest.
5. Confidentiality and Integrity
Reviewers and editors must protect unpublished manuscripts, research data, and confidential editorial information.
Peer review must be conducted independently, objectively, and without unauthorized generative AI assistance.
RMNS does not guarantee acceptance or publication within a fixed timeframe.









